Take-Home-Exams
The Alternative Digital Examination Method to In-Person Exams
Here you will find all the information about the implementation of Take-Home Exams (THE) at the University of Hamburg.
Take-Home Exams are "individual and written or electronically interactive examination performances (e.g., multiple-choice), conducted at a freely chosen location without supervision. This examination format is suitable for implementation in digital examination environments and particularly for open, complex tasks. It can be used both formatively and summatively" (Witt/Bartke 2022).
The examination method Take-Home Exam is permissible if it is enshrined in the applicable examination regulations or subject-specific provisions.
The Faculty of Law provides information about examination practices with Take-Home Exams on separate pages.
Concept
What is a take-home exam?
In a take-home exam, students work on one or more predetermined questions in writing or electronically, independently and without supervision, possibly using permitted resources, within a set processing duration and within a processing time frame (a deadline) that may be longer than the processing duration itself.
The examination regulations give examiners latitude in how they design the exam, including the processing duration. It is:
- 120–180 minutes in the Faculty of Law
- 60–240 minutes in the Faculties of WiSo, MIN, and Psychology and Human Movement Science
- 60–180 minutes in the Business School
Within these limits, examiners set the specific processing duration. The examination regulations do not specify the processing time frame itself. As a general rule: the longer the processing time frame between issuing and returning the exam, the more opportunity students have to conduct their own research – this should be taken into account didactically when designing the assignment.
This results in two implementation variants:
Variant 1: Processing duration plus technical buffer
The processing time frame equals the processing duration plus a buffer (a proven value: 15 minutes) for distribution, upload, and the declaration of independence. All students work on the exam at the same time; the narrow time frame strongly limits opportunities for research, so that assignments similar to those in in-person exams are possible.
Variant 2: Processing time frame significantly longer than processing duration
Examiners set a longer, binding time frame (e.g., 24 hours, several days) within which students complete the exam, at a time of their own choosing, within the set processing duration. The longer deadline allows for more opportunities for research, which should be taken into account when designing the assignment.
In both variants, examiners can also specify the scope of the submission (e.g., page count). A trial run with students before the actual exam is recommended; in any case, it is important that the "rules of the game" are communicated in advance.
What information for students should supplement the assignment?
- text fields for personal information (first name, last name, matriculation number)
- a specific list of permitted resources (anything not listed is considered impermissible – this matters for any later allegations of academic dishonesty)
- format, submission method, and deadline details (file format, font/font size, page length, line spacing, etc.), with a file template if applicable
- a pre-formulated declaration of independence that students can adopt; plus a note that only students registered for the exam in STiNE are permitted to take it
Notes on exams in Openolat as well as the declaration of independence can be found in the course template (see Technical Implementation).
Didactic guidelines
The exam format should be guided by the course's learning objectives: for simple recall of knowledge, the multiple-choice format is suitable; for higher-level learning objectives (application, critical reflection), thesis-like free-text formats following the open-book principle are suitable – in that case, the assignment should be complex enough to prevent mere reproduction of knowledge.
If only the multiple-choice format is practical for larger courses, the level of competency being tested can be raised by asking for the best-fitting answer instead of true/false questions, or by using short case vignettes (see also the University of Bern's "Anleitung zur Herstellung von MC-Fragen und MC-Prüfungen" [guide to creating multiple-choice questions and exams, in German]).
Recommended: introduce and practice the format and procedure during the course (e.g., with a practice take-home exam, possibly with feedback as part of active participation), and announce requirements and assessment criteria in advance.
What technical equipment should be assumed for completion?
The exam should not require any special hardware or platform-dependent software; different operating systems, office suites, and devices should be assumed. Access to the assignment must be possible largely independent of individual technical equipment and must be accessible.
In practice, PDF uploads have proven to be a frequent source of problems in the Faculty of Law – if this format is used, students should be informed early on. If the exam requires a continuous online connection (e.g., the multiple-choice format), this must be communicated in good time so that students can arrange a workstation with a stable connection if needed; on-site workstations can also be provided for a limited number of examinees (clarify demand with the student office early on). The problem can be significantly reduced if the exam is instead designed so that tasks are worked on offline after downloading and only uploaded again afterward. With a longer processing time frame, students with inadequate internet access can also use the workstations at the university that can be booked through the library.
Practice at the WiSo Faculty
Loaner laptops are available through the WiSo Research Lab.
Practice at the EW Faculty
If a workstation/computer is unavailable, the exam can be taken using a device from the Media Center in university rooms (contact: Birgit Veelders).
Organization
When and how do examinees receive the assignments?
The assignment is released at the time specified in the exam schedule; in Openolat, this release can be automated. Releasing the assignment via STiNE is currently not technically possible.
Announcing the processing duration/time frame and changes
Both are published by the student office in the course description ("Additional notes on exams") – for data protection reasons, login information must not be included there. The processing duration is also published in the exam round; for Socioeconomics, the processing duration and release time are additionally announced as an exam date in STiNE (with a reference to the course description for the processing time frame). Changes, in particular extensions of the processing duration, are only possible in coordination with the student office and, as a rule, are no longer possible once the course registration period has begun at the latest.
Please check whether faculty-specific notes differ from this.
Release of the exam assignment
Only students registered for the exam in STiNE at the time of release may take part (deregistration is possible up to three days before release). Releasing the assignment via Openolat has proven effective, ideally in a separate course set up exclusively for the exam. Email is possible in principle, but is harder to trace and carries greater legal risk.
Submission
The submission method is determined by the examiners. In Openolat, students upload their documents themselves or work directly in the browser; submissions after the deadline can be technically blocked. For submission by email, the required format should be made transparent (including the matriculation number for unambiguous identification). Recommended: set the processing time frame at least 15 minutes longer than the processing duration, to allow time for downloading, converting, and uploading (coordinate with the student office).
Coordinating dates with in-person exams
The student office takes take-home exams into account in the exam schedule in the same way as in-person exams; the dates set there are binding.
Please check whether faculty-specific notes differ from this.
Communicating the exam details
Via the course information in STiNE, and if necessary additionally via the learning platform used (e.g., Openolat).
Examination Law
Permitted resources
This is determined by the examiners.
Detecting plagiarism
Unlike in in-person exams, for take-home exams it must be determined in advance how the use of passages from other sources is to be indicated – taking into account how familiar students are (particularly early in their studies) with good scientific practice and discipline-specific citation styles. Assignments should be designed so that merely reproducing the literature is not sufficient for a solution; for longer processing time frames involving original writing, students should be reminded of the obligation to cite sources.
Since cases of academic dishonesty usually only become apparent during grading, establishing them and the burden of proof lie with the examiners; the student office provides advisory support and handles the notification (STiNE, and a formal notice if necessary). Computer-assisted plagiarism checks by external services are possible. Handwritten solutions make copy-paste plagiarism more difficult, but require that students be informed of the photo/scan requirement well before the assignment is released and that they have suitable hardware (otherwise the university must provide a way to do so); the downside is poorer legibility, which eliminates the roughly 20% time saving in grading that would otherwise be possible.
Technical problems with submission/access
Students must report problems immediately (an obligation to take action; legally, a formal objection), in practice e.g. by email. If the problem can be resolved, the examinee may be granted a short extension and continue taking the exam; otherwise, the exam attempt is annulled and a new date is made available – this always applies if the cause lies with the university. If the problem was on the student's side, they must subsequently provide credible evidence of it (e.g., a connection log, proof of a power outage); if they cannot do so, the exam is considered failed. The support procedure during the exam is to be clarified within each faculty.
Practice at the EW Faculty
If credible technical reasons are provided, the student office allows a resit.
Late submission
Cases of no fault of the student's own: see above. A late submission for which the student is at fault is considered failed; the burden of proof for the delay lies with the examiners, who must announce the missed deadline in STiNE as with in-person exams and retain the corresponding evidence for a possible appeals procedure for at least one year from the date the missed deadline was announced. In Openolat, submission after the deadline can be technically and automatically blocked.
Exceeding the processing duration within the time frame
If the time frame is set to be longer than the processing duration, compliance with the duration cannot be strictly enforced technically (Openolat, too, does not log the actual time spent working on the exam). Exams should therefore be designed so that extending the work up to the limit of the time frame provides students with no added benefit.
Clarity of the assignment
Queries from examinees must be answered for all participants; with short time frames, defects in the assignment may no longer be able to be remedied (clarification, e.g., via Openolat, to all participants). Students should be informed in advance to keep an eye on messages during the exam – under their obligation to take action, they otherwise cannot claim they were unaware of a message. If an examinee nonetheless claims not to have received a message, this must be formally objected to as soon as it becomes known and reviewed by the examiners; if an actual delivery problem is confirmed, the message can be delivered again while the exam is still running (if necessary with a time extension), otherwise the objection has no further consequences. If the problem only becomes known after the exam, the attempt must be annulled. Recommended: run through the assignment as a test before the exam begins.
Students not registered for the exam
Exams by students who were not registered for the exam must generally not be graded – please consult with the student office in advance; they will clarify the legality of the student's participation and advise on how to proceed.
Compensatory measures
Approved extensions of processing time and break arrangements also apply to take-home exams; individual submission deadlines can be set in Openolat. Extensions apply to the processing duration, not the time frame – if the latter was already set more generously for everyone, a buffer (ideally also at least 15 minutes) should also be granted as part of the compensatory measure; where the time frame is already long, individual measures are often unnecessary. To compensate for physical limitations, adequate exam conditions can usually already be created in a student's home environment; for special requirements regarding the design of the assignment (e.g., visual impairment), a simultaneous but technically separate administration of the exam can also be useful.
For more detail: Which compensatory measures for in-person exams can be applied to take-home exams? (PDF, in German)
Multiple-choice format
For automatically graded tests, the narrow scope for answers constitutes a particular legal requirement:
"In the event of disputes, examinees and examiners cannot engage in a nuanced exchange of views. The multiple-choice format therefore requires a different form of performance assessment. The examiner's actual work is shifted forward in time and consists solely of selecting the examination material, formulating the questions, and determining the possible answers. Multiple-choice exams are generally permissible at the University of Hamburg. However, they require an explicit provision in the respective examination regulations or subject-specific provisions. Because of these particular features, the design of the examination procedure is of special importance. It is also important that the assessment principles applied are precisely specified" (quoted from UHH, Department 31, Guidance Note No. 11: "Rechtliche Besonderheiten von Antwort-Wahl-Verfahren (Multiple Choice) als Prüfungsart" ["Legal Particularities of the Multiple-Choice Format as an Examination Method," in German]).
See also the overview with the online calculator: https://dl-wiso.blogs.uni-hamburg.de/so-bewerten-sie-pruefungen-im-antwort-wahl-verfahren-korrekt/ (German only)
Technical Implementation
Most take-home exams at UHH are run via Openolat – as a learning environment that is already familiar to most, it supports the organization, design, grading, feedback, and documentation of the exam. Since most people are already familiar with the platform, this section is largely limited to the basic understanding that is important for an exam in addition to everyday course work; more detailed, click-by-click instructions can be found in the linked HelpCards and in the user manual.
Separate course
Create a separate course for each take-home exam (do not use the course's regular teaching course), named according to the pattern "Name of the course – Take-Home-Exam," and keep it, with all its content, after the exam.
Access for examinees approved in STiNE
You should only allow those students to access the Openolat course containing the take-home exam who are approved for the exam – not all students who are taking the course.
So far, examinees must be granted access to an Openolat course manually. Below we describe two approaches: one for examiners, and one for staff in student offices who can assist with this step. In both cases, the aim is to copy the matriculation numbers of the approved examinees and use them to make the examinees participants in the Openolat course via "Import Members."
Attention: If at all possible, you should only carry out these steps after the end of the registration and deregistration period!
How examiners can copy the matriculation numbers
Instructions can be found in the HelpCard Participant Import with Campus Management Reporting.
How student office staff can copy the matriculation numbers
The matriculation numbers can be obtained via the exam round – select the participants, use "Print" to create an export with the options "Grades," "Passed Exams," and "Failed Exams," and save it as a CSV file (manually set the file extension to ".csv" so that the file can be opened in, for example, Excel).
Import examinees into the Openolat course as "Members" by matriculation number and make them "Participants"
To do this, in the Openolat course for the take-home exam go to "Administration" – "Member Management" – "Import Members," paste in the copied matriculation numbers (exactly one per line), and assign the examinees the "Participant" member role.
Openolat will now offer to notify the examinees by email that they have been added to the course. This would also give the examinees a link to the course right away.
Please note that the course "status" should remain set to "Preparation" from this point until all preparatory work is complete. You should also keep the course address to yourself for now. Because as soon as the course status is set to "Published," examinees can see the course and access all content visible and accessible within it – or not, which creates uncertainty. Keeping the course status at "Preparation" and withholding the course address prevents queries about the accessibility of the take-home exam content at this early stage.
Attention: Openolat can only grant a membership right to people who have already logged into the system at least once. When a person logs in for the first time with their university user ID, Openolat synchronizes data with the central user database and stores, in effect, a copy in Openolat. From that point on, the person is "known" to the platform.
If you receive the message "The following users were not found: [matriculation numbers]," you must ask these examinees to first log into Openolat for the first time and let you know afterward. You can then add these individuals one by one.
Two ways to conduct the exam
The Task course element is suitable for document submissions (free text, thesis-like): students only need to be online for the assignment and submission steps, and can work offline in between. The Test course element is suitable for the automatically graded multiple-choice format, but requires a continuous online connection for the entire duration of the exam – this should be weighed against the assignment when choosing the course element. For both course elements: questions or task variants can be randomized to make collusion more difficult, and a question or task that is later found to be flawed can be corrected uniformly for all participants (e.g., by crediting points).
The core principle of time-based access control
Visibility and Access for a course element are two separate settings, and this is crucial for an exam:
The element containing the take-home exam should be visible in the course menu from the start, so that students can get their bearings in advance about where the exam will take place – actual access (opening, working on, and submitting it), by contrast, should only be granted on a date-dependent basis once the processing time frame begins.
Recommendation, coordinated with Department 31: This access remains in place for up to one year beyond the end of the processing time frame, so that students can later verify what they submitted. In addition, the assignment or submission itself can be technically and strictly limited to the end of the processing time frame, so that no further submission is possible after that. For compensatory measures, individually different deadlines can be set for specific students.
Declaration of Independence
For reasons of examination law, it must not be obtained in advance, but must be made in writing, essentially "at the time of submission." Suitable, legally coordinated forms are included in the course template (a handwritten signature is not required).
Assessment
Exam results must first be announced in STiNE, and only afterward in Openolat. To get support with grading, staff can be assigned the course role "Coach" (access to the assessment, but no right to edit or delete the course) – beforehand, it is advisable to back up the submissions/test results.
Stumbling Blocks
Changes in the course editor only take effect after "Publishing"; students only see the course once its status is "Published," regardless of other access rules; a sample solution that is enabled but not uploaded in the Task course element makes the entire element invisible; after voluntarily leaving the course, gradable results are retained, but are then only visible to "Owners," no longer to "Coaches."
Course Template
You can find an Openolat course that can serve as a template for your take-home exam in the platform's catalog under "Course Templates" – or directly at https://www.openolat.uni-hamburg.de/auth/RepositoryEntry/130188257. An English-language version is available at https://www.openolat.uni-hamburg.de/auth/RepositoryEntry/262307971/.
Attention: Once again, a reminder that all of this is merely practical, operational advice. We cannot take over the responsibility of your role as an examiner. Please try out your own take-home exam course and the process in detail yourself. And above all: have your students take a practice take-home exam early on.